You are here: Home » the Blog » Workouts, Arbitrage, & Hedges » Use Arbitrage! The Tribune Company Example

Use Arbitrage! The Tribune Company Example

By Joe Ponzio on December 4, 2007  |  27 comments

Late last week, the FCC approved Tribune Company to own print and broadcast media in the same market. Why was this important? Tribune Company (TRB) is going private and the FCC approval was critical to this transaction. Without FCC approval, the deal might not have gone through. With that hurdle out of the way, what's to stop it now?

And how can we make money from it?

The Details

Real estate tycoon Sam Zell is planning a buyout of Tribune Company (TRB) at the end of the year for $34 a share. Let me rephrase that—the company is expected to go private in the next 27 days and plans to buy its stock from shareholders at $34 a share.

If the deal can't be completed by December 31st, the company will continue its quest to privatize and will begin paying shareholders an annualized 8% interest rate on their shares until the company goes private.

The Stock

The stock is currently trading around $30.50. If the deal goes through by December 31st, yesterday's buyers will earn about 11% in a month—an annualized return of more than 265%.

The Hurdles

Very little is stopping this buyout plan now. The FCC hurdle was the major one. Though the company needs to get the deal done by the end of the month to qualify for tax credits, the paperwork seems to be in order to push the deal through no matter what.

Let's put some probabilities on this and try to quantify the risks:

A Pabrai / Kelly Risk Analysis

What are the odds that the deal will go through by the end of the month? I've seen bigger deals fall through for no apparent reason other than one company couldn't get its ass in gear. Remember GE's planned 8 billion acquisition of one of Abbott's divisions earlier this year? Best as I can tell, Abbott fumbled and couldn't get the required paperwork done in time and GE pulled out.

Even though Tribune has been planning to do this deal since early this year, let's assume that there is a 50% chance that the company will complete its buyout by December 31.

What if the company can't get it done in the next four weeks? We know the company still wants to privatize and is offering a premium of 8% annualized if it can't get the deal done by the end of 2007. Odds of it getting done in early to mid-2008? I'll say 30%.

Of course, the deal can fall through and not close at all. In that case, today's buyers would simply hold Tribune stock. Let's say there is a nearly 20% chance of that happening.

Finally—the doomsday case. There is a small chance that the deal will fall through and that the company will fall off the face of the earth by the end of 2007. Sure, it's a small chance. Still, we'll ascribe a <1% chance of that happening.

Making Sense of The Odds

In this merger/buyout arbitrage play, I estimate that there is a 50% chance to make an annualized return of >265% by the end of 2007. If the deal can't close until June of 2008, I believe that there is a 30% chance of earning 30% or greater on an annualized basis once you add in the 8% interest being paid.

I believe that there is a one in five (or 20%) chance that the deal won't go through. In that case, I'll hold Tribune stock, or sell it at a loss. On news of the deal failing, I'll put that loss at 15% if I can sell around $26.

If the company goes defunct in the next 30 days, I'll lose everything.

The Odds: How I See Them

When the odds are in your favor, bet big. I believe that the Tribune buyout presents an interesting opportunity to make a substantial amount of money in a very short timespan. It's not guaranteed or risk-free; still, I believe that the odds are in favor of today's buyers.

Use Arbitrage

Whether or not you buy Tribune stock today, you should consider the use of arbitrage in your investing. Whether you consider pure buyout arbitrage like we are doing with Tribune, or you are using a form of arbitrage in selling options against your positions, the use of arbitrage might make the difference between a good retirement and a great one.

Written by Joe Ponzio on December 4, 2007

Joe Ponzio is the managing partner of the Ponzio Investors Funds and owner of Ponzio Capital Inc, a registered investment advisory and deep value portfolio management firm. The author of F Wall Street (the book and the website), his articles have appeared in hundreds of financial media, including Financial Planning Magazine, CNBC.com, Yahoo! Finance, and Reuters. He has appeared numerous times nationally on both radio and television, and has presented at universities and seminars across the United States.

Read more articles like this online at www.fwallstreet.com.
To learn more about Joe's portfolio management services, visit www.ponziocapital.com.
The Discussion
MikeR' gravatar

MikeR
Dec 4th, 2007

Writing the December 27.5-strike puts looks interesting. They are going for $1.20 a share and expire on Dec. 22. That reduces your risk to an entry price of about $26.30 per share plus commissions.
Night' gravatar

Night
Dec 4th, 2007
72 comments

How did you calculate the amount that will be paid to each shareholder? I am not sure how this buyout/privatization thing works..

Thanks Joe :)
Night,

The buyout price was publicly announced. You can see the press release here.
Night' gravatar

Night
Dec 4th, 2007
72 comments

Thanks a bunch, I did a quick google search but the articles it picked up just had some 8.2 billion figure. I will try to be more thorough next time..

Thanks again!
Dave Miller' gravatar

Dave Miller
Dec 4th, 2007

MikeR,

I like your idea about selling the downside puts and collecting $1.20. A trade I like better is doing the Jan '08 30 buy write for $3.00. The reason I like this a bit better is that you get downside protection down to $27.00 (vs your $26.30), but you are able to participate in the upside for $3.00. So for giving up .70 cents of downside protection you receive $3.00 upside profit.
Steve' gravatar

Steve
Dec 4th, 2007

Mike I don't know if I fully follow your planning. Are you saying buy and sell the Jan 08 $30 strike price?
Mike Melloch (MikeR)' gravatar

Mike Melloch (MikeR)
Dec 4th, 2007
71 comments

Dave,

Very nice idea with the buy-writes.

(MikeR)' gravatar

(MikeR)
Dec 4th, 2007
71 comments

Steve,

I am selling the Dec. 27.5-strike puts. I sold them for $1.20. They expire December 22. If TRB is above 27.50 on Dec 22 I pocket the $1.20 per share. If TRB is below 27.5 on Dec 22 I am forced to buy TRB at $27.50, no matter what TRB is trading at. So if TRB goes to zero in the next 2.5 weeks I loose ($27.50-$1.20) per share, my maximum risk.
mule65' gravatar

mule65
Dec 4th, 2007

Hmmm, doesn't the heavy OTM Jan08 Put activity indicate buyout doubt?
J' gravatar

J
Dec 4th, 2007

So does this post mainly refer to options or can it be applied to regular trading?
(MikeR)' gravatar

(MikeR)
Dec 4th, 2007
71 comments

J,

Joe's post was regarding regular trading of this arbitrage situation. I started the option thing.
giggsy' gravatar

giggsy
Dec 4th, 2007

Joe,

Great article and timely as well. There is a similar arbitrage situation here in Canada regarding the BCE buy out.

There is an opportunity (not as great as yours) to make 10% in the next 5 months.

giggsy
Jeff' gravatar

Jeff
Dec 5th, 2007

I like what I've heard on the options so far.

Joe- your thoughts on a possible option play here?
Steve' gravatar

Steve
Dec 5th, 2007

Does anyone have a comment on the liklihood, as of today, of the transaction still going through given the US Senate's ruling to impose a multi-month review period to allowing dual ownership of media in the 20 largest markets.

I feel this could hamper the ability of the buyer of Tribune to offload some of the properties in order to pay their soon-to-be large debt load.

Also would that decision over-rule the special situation given to Tribune?

It seems that the market is reacting negatively to these announcements giving possibly a better implied return should the deal go through.


Regardless of the outcome for this particular position I feel that it is a great example of keeping your eyes open for opportunity.

Steve
Night' gravatar

Night
Dec 5th, 2007
72 comments

I am not experienced with this sort of activity in the least, but from an article on MSN

"The legislation, even if successful, is not expected to affect the proposed $8.2 billion buyout of the Tribune Co., which was approved by the FCC last week. It is unclear whether there would be any potential long-term impact on the company."
- source

Not sure if the 'unclear potential impact' will have an effect on Sam Zell's buying decision or not..

Also, from the press release on Nov. 30th

"The company also asked for an extension of existing waivers of the FCC's cross-ownership rule in New York, Los Angeles, Hartford and South Florida -- markets in which Tribune operates both a newspaper and television station. The waivers granted today are temporary, pending the outcome of the FCC's ongoing review of media ownership rules. In Chicago, the company will be exempt from cross-ownership restrictions through a permanent waiver provision. "
-source

So, I guess they will always have the cross-ownership in Chicago.. but the potential of losing the ones in NY, LA, Hartford, South Florida may deter the deal?

I am completely new to analyzing this sort of deal.. How strong of a negative effect is this?
As you'll see in the blog post, I put the chance of the deal failing at about 20%. This is certainly not a "no-brainer", but it does present an opportunity with great upside potential.

The proposed legislation shouldn't affect the Tribune deal as it will affect future reviews. Tribune's waiver will likely be grandfathered in as it was granted when the legislation was not in place.

I looked at the OTM (out of the money) put and call activity, and it appears to be fairly balanced. I never use investor sentiment or price as a guage because, for the most part, investors and institutions are generally wrong and usually earn returns equal to or less than the markets.

What's the move here? Consider buying Tribune with some protection.
  1. Throw a sell stop on your position to limit your downside;
  2. sell calls against your position to lower your effective net basis;
  3. roll the dice and buy TRB because you think the deal will go through;
  4. find a new opportunity.
If you have a ton of doubt or are entirely unsure and uncomfortable, move on. I say it a lot, but only because it is the right strategy!

Hope that helps!
augustabound' gravatar

augustabound
Dec 5th, 2007

Where do you find out about this? Do you just keep your eyes and ears open for M and A activity and privatization deals?
You just have to keep your eyes open for opportunities. Of course, it helps that I'm in Chicago and this is a Chicago deal. It's big news here.
Night' gravatar

Night
Dec 5th, 2007
72 comments

This is all an interesting experience atleast!
How's the book shopping going? I don't think we've gotten an update lately.
(MikeR)' gravatar

(MikeR)
Dec 5th, 2007
71 comments

Joel Greenblatt in his book "You Can Be a Stock Market Genius" (yes the title is a turn off) has many interesting case stodies of arbitrage, spin-offs, restructuring, bankruptcy, etc plays. If I recall correctly he talks about reading the Wall Street Journal, Barron's, etc to find these plays.
Night' gravatar

Night
Dec 6th, 2007
72 comments

Thanks, MikeR.. I think I might pick that up! These sort of deals sure are interesting :D.

Anyone get lucky, or was smart enough, to of bought it yesterday when it was at $28 or so? News today seems to of nearly sealed the deal..

Time for me to hang on til the 1st or for some serious news, in any case.
(MikeR)' gravatar

(MikeR)
Dec 6th, 2007
71 comments

Night,

I was really close to buying my 27.5 strike puts back yesterday and take my losses when it got close to 28, lol. Luckily I did not!
Jeff' gravatar

Jeff
Dec 6th, 2007

I've owned this since about 27.50. Here's a good couple of posts on the topic by Saul Sterman. He's been adamant about the deal going through since August.

http://www.crossprofit.com/article.asp?id=140
I'm not a big fan of puts. I think I'll post my reasoning tomorrow.

MikeR - Close call...how short are your nails after last week? Did you bite them off entirely?

Night - I'll have some news on the book soon.
(MikeR)' gravatar

(MikeR)
Dec 10th, 2007
71 comments

Joe,

Yes, they are entirely gone, lol. I look forward to your thoughts on writing puts.
(MikeR)' gravatar

(MikeR)
Dec 19th, 2007
71 comments

Looking good, I sold some more Dec 27.5 stirke puts this morning for $0.75.
(MikeR)' gravatar

(MikeR)
Aug 7th, 2008
71 comments

What am I missing with EAS?

EAS is a diversified utility in the northeast. EAS is trading at $25 with a 52-week low of $22.26.

Iberdrola is trying to acquire EAS for $28.50 cash per share of EAS. There are
concerns that NY regulators will impose unacceptable condition on the deal and it will fall through.

The September $22.50 strike puts are bid at $0.90. The worst case seems the deal
falls through before the puts expire in 44 days and EAS trades down to the
neighborhood of its 52-week low. So you end up with EAS put to you at $22.50, with a dividend yield at that price of 5.5%, plus the $0.90 per share put premium.

I must be missing something for the MMs to be pricing such a premium in those
puts?
Join The Discussion

Your Name
Feb 9th, 2010

Remember me on this computer
To help keep the F Wall Street website free from comment spam, we require that you have javascript enabled to post a comment. Please turn on javascript and refresh this page to load the comment form.

Joe Ponzio's F Wall Street

Submitting Your Comment

Please wait while your comment is submitted. (It may take a moment.) Comments on F Wall Street are moderated which means that your comment will appear only after it has been reviewed by Joe. Comments are typically reviewed and approved (or denied) quickly, except between 11:30PM and 5:00AM (CST) – Joe has to sleep some time!

Joe Ponzio's F Wall Street

Thank You For Participating!

Thank you for participating on F Wall Street. Once your comment has been approved, it will appear here. While waiting, check out some other articles on the blog or click here to return to the article.

» Buy F Wall Street at Amazon.com

Excel 2007|Excel 2003
(ZIP, 168kb) (ZIP, 138kb)

Search F Wall Street

Powered by Google

Subscribe to F Wall Street

E-mail or RSS updates. And it's free!

Enter your e-mail address below

Sun @ 1:14AM | View comment
mike said,

ROIC is not based on earnings. it's just EBIT * (1-t) / invested capital. The flaw with ROIC...
What The Heck Is CROIC?

Thu @ 8:00AM | View comment
Cale Smith said,

New Ponzio Capital site looks great, Joe, and good to see you back posting!
BreitBurn Energy: Playing the Commodities Crash

Wed @ 5:50PM | View comment
kalidasa said,

in correction to an earlier post, it is Sham Gad(www.gadcapital.com) or www.shamgad.blogspot.com
Hedge Funds and the Early Buffett Partnership

Tue @ 3:29PM | View comment
Joe Ponzio said,

I think it got overheated. I still feel like it's a good long-term holding (if the buy price is right)....
Is Nutrisystem Healthy?

Tue @ 2:48PM | View comment
Nutrisystem Coupon said,

Dude, what happened to this stock? You would think in January this stock would be jumping through the roof...
Is Nutrisystem Healthy?